Stillwater Homes under $400,000

Stillwater Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Stillwater, Oklahoma – a charming city that beautifully blends small-town warmth with vibrant community spirit. Nestled in Payne County, Stillwater is not just home to Oklahoma State University; it’s a thriving hub of culture and opportunity. With a rich history, picturesque parks, and a lively downtown area, Stillwater offers residents an engaging lifestyle filled with local art, music, and culinary delights.

For those seeking a place to call home, Stillwater boasts a diverse range of properties, including an impressive selection of homes under $400,000. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, you’ll find a variety of options that cater to your needs and budget. From charming bungalows with character to modern family homes with spacious backyards, the real estate market here is as inviting as the community itself.

Imagine settling into a cozy home just minutes away from the vibrant campus life, enjoying the scenic beauty of Boomer Lake, or exploring the numerous parks and trails that make Stillwater a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. The affordability of homes in this area means that you can enjoy all the amenities of a lively city without breaking the bank.

With its friendly atmosphere, excellent schools, and a strong sense of community, Stillwater is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Come explore the possibilities and discover why so many are choosing to make Stillwater their home. Your dream home awaits!

Newest Stillwater Homes under $400,000

4021 Wagon Drive, Stillwater
$377,500
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1258000 MLS
*SELLER OFFERING $5,000 IN CONCESSIONS! Use it your way—toward upgrades, closing costs, or a rate buy-down—your possibilities start here! For added peace of mind, this home includes the standard builder’s warranty plus an additional 10-year Limited Structural third party Warranty through RWC, offering long-term confidence in your investment! An Exceptional New Build with Space, Style & Endless Possibilities! This exceptional home offers a unique opportunity to secure a thoughtfully designed new build by an award-winning metro home builder. Set on .73 acres MOL, this 2,044 SF home delivers space where it matters most—inside and out. The floor plan includes 5 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, perfect for growing households, guests, or flexible living needs. Car enthusiasts and hobbyists will love the garage setup: a wider and deeper 2-car garage, plus an additional 3rd and 4th car garage with drive-thru access, complete with 10x8 overhead doors at both the front and back—a highly desirable feature! Enjoy outdoor living with a covered front porch and covered patio, ideal for relaxing or entertaining. Inside, the home features hand-textured walls and ceilings, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a spacious primary shower, and an oversized hot water heater for added comfort and efficiency—plus so much more. Opportunities like this don’t come along often—brand-new construction, incredible garage space, acreage, and a trusted award-winning builder. Get in early and watch this impressive home come to life! HOA is $250 per year. Estimated completion Mid-December. Schedule your private showing today!

4021 Wagon Drive, Stillwater

1119 S Pine Street, Stillwater
$259,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1256329 MLS
REMODELED AND MOVE IN READY! Renewed, refreshed and ready for you! Come see this charming home with three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, one attached and one large detached garage/shop. (14x30 with electric) Enjoy the beautiful curb appeal with the new stylish brick across the front of the home with a decorative address plaque. Enter the front door under a welcoming covered front porch. When you open the door you will see a large living area which opens to the kitchen and dining area. The newly refinished hardwood flooring is rare and unique with both white oak and red oak wood. The hardwood flooring is in the living area, all three bedrooms and the hallway. NO carpet is in the home for those with allergies. The kitchen has all new cabinetry, 3 cm marble countertops, undermount sink, insinkerator garbage disposal with counter push button turn on/off, hardware and opens to the dining area. The laundry has been moved into this area from the garage. The interior of the home, the interior of attached garage, the exterior of the home and even the detached garage have all been painted. All new lighting and Champion windows have been installed throughout the home. More updates include a roof, garage door, gas meter, replaced the main water line in the yard, water lines, tree removal and pruning, vanities, doors, mirrors, toilets, window treatments, appliances including a Bosch dishwasher and much more. There is an extra wide driveway for more parking and to get to the detached garage. This garage/workshop is behind the fence that encloses the backyard. There is a covered back patio that is on the east side of the home for enjoyable evenings in the shade. Convenient to OSU, medical, downtown, shopping and the new YMCA being built. More before pictures can be shared if you want to see the transformation. Owner is a Realtor in the state of Oklahoma.

1119 S Pine Street, Stillwater

204 S Old Central Drive, Stillwater
$312,500
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1255831 MLS
6,000 BUILDER INCENTIVE + PREFERRED LENDER CREDIT = MORE BUYING POWER! BIG SPACE, BEAUTIFUL FINISHES & BIG SAVINGS! Why settle when you can have brand-new construction, beautiful designer finishes, and incentives that help make homeownership more affordable? The builder is offering $6,000 IN SELLER CONCESSIONS that may be used towards options, allowable closing costs, an interest rate buydown, or other lender-approved expenses! BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE! Use the preferred lender and receive an ADDITIONAL CREDIT equal to 1% OF YOUR LOAN AMOUNT! Financing options include Conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, and in-house down payment assistance programs, subject to qualification. Seller has accepted a contingent contract. Now, let's talk about the HOME! Welcome to the Richmond, offering over 2072 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space with 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and a 2-car garage! Step inside to discover an inviting open-concept design where the kitchen, dining, and living areas flow together beautifully. The kitchen is sure to impress with gorgeous quartz countertops, crisp white cabinetry, a stylish white tile backsplash, GE appliances, and a center island perfect for gathering. The main level features a private primary suite, two additional bedrooms, and convenient laundry space. HEAD UPSTAIRS FOR EVEN MORE POSSIBILITIES! A fourth bedroom, full bathroom, and spacious bonus room offer endless flexibility for a media room, game room, guest retreat, or whatever your lifestyle needs! Beautiful Craftsman-inspired exterior details, a covered patio, and carefully coordinated interior finishes add to the appeal of this exciting new home. UNDER CONSTRUCTION with estimated completion in approximately 4.5; months! Why wait to start planning your next chapter? Take advantage of these incredible incentives and make the Richmond your next address! Schedule your showing TODAY! HOA is $225 per year.

204 S Old Central Drive, Stillwater

2120 W 23rd Avenue, Stillwater
$246,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1255087 MLS
Welcome to this stunning, fully remodeled home in an exceptional Stillwater location near Babcock Park, Stillwater’s dog park, OSU, and downtown! Situated on a spacious lot backing to an open greenbelt, this home combines timeless character with thoughtful updates inside and out. The refreshed exterior features fresh paint, accent shutters, and a new two-car garage, creating inviting curb appeal from the moment you arrive. Inside, refinished hardwood floors flow throughout the home, adding warmth and classic charm to the spacious living area. The open layout transitions seamlessly into the dining room, where access to the back deck and expansive backyard extends your living and entertaining space outdoors. The beautifully updated kitchen features fresh cabinetry, new quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and classic backsplash tile, all complemented by a window above the sink overlooking the backyard. A spacious laundry room just off the dining area offers convenient access and additional access to the garage allows for effortless everyday living. Down the hallway, two generously sized secondary bedrooms feature refinished hardwood floors, ample closet space, and abundant natural light. They share a beautifully remodeled bathroom complete with a freestanding tub, spacious vanity, and timeless finishes. Privately tucked away at the back of the home, the primary suite offers a spacious closet, natural light, and an inviting en suite bathroom designed to maximize both style and functionality. An updated vanity and fixtures pair beautifully with the walk-in shower to create a spa-inspired retreat. Outside, a new deck, mature trees, updated fencing, a spacious backyard, and the peaceful greenbelt backdrop create a wonderful setting to relax or entertain. With extensive updates, timeless character, and an outstanding location close to parks, OSU, and downtown Stillwater, this move-in-ready home is one you won't want to miss!

2120 W 23rd Avenue, Stillwater

6602 Cowboy Trail Way, Stillwater
$296,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1255263 MLS
$10,000 IN SELLER CONCESSIONS PLUS A 1% PREFERRED LENDER CREDIT! TWO INCENTIVES, ONE INCREDIBLE OPPORTUNITY! Why settle for ordinary when you can have a home designed around YOUR lifestyle? Welcome to the Phoenix Plan, featuring 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a 2-car garage, and a BONUS FLEX SPACE that takes versatility to the next level! Whether you need a home office, playroom, hobby room, or additional living area, this thoughtfully designed floor plan delivers! The open-concept kitchen, dining, and living spaces create the perfect setting for entertaining or relaxing at home. Retreat to your private primary suite featuring an ensuite bath, soaking tub, and walk-in closet. Three additional bedrooms offer flexibility for guests and everyday living. A separate laundry room and covered back patio add even more convenience! AND HERE'S THE EXCITING PART! The seller is offering $10,000 in concessions PLUS the preferred lender is offering a credit equal to 1% of the loan amount! This lender incentive is available with eligible Conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, and in-house down payment assistance financing programs. That's TWO opportunities to help reduce your out-of-pocket expenses! CURRENTLY UNDER CONSTRUCTION! Estimated completion end of January 2027. Don't miss your chance to make this beautiful new home yours! Schedule your showing and ask about the available financing incentives today! Lender credit subject to loan program guidelines, lender approval, and applicable restrictions. HOA is $225 per year

6602 Cowboy Trail Way, Stillwater

6516 Cowboy Trail Way, Stillwater
$289,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1255213 MLS
TWO INCREDIBLE INCENTIVES + ONE GORGEOUS NEW HOME! The builder is offering a $10,000 INCENTIVE, and the preferred lender is offering a SEPARATE 1% CREDIT OF THE LOAN AMOUNT! That's TWO opportunities to make your new home purchase even sweeter! Meet the Madison plan—a beautifully designed 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offering 1,758 sq. ft. of thoughtfully planned living space and a 2-car garage! From the charming exterior with eye-catching architectural details to the spacious, open-concept interior, this home is designed to impress! The heart of the home features a fabulous kitchen with a generous center island, walk-in pantry, and plenty of room to cook, gather, and entertain! The kitchen flows effortlessly into the inviting living area and breakfast space, creating a layout that feels open, comfortable, and connected. Retreat to your private primary suite featuring an en-suite bath and spacious walk-in closet, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, hobbies, or a home office. And here's a feature you'll appreciate—an ADDITIONAL HALF BATH for guests! No more sharing your private bathroom when company comes over! Step outside to your covered patio, the perfect spot for morning coffee, weekend cookouts, or relaxing after a long day. With stylish design, smart use of space, and TWO SEPARATE FINANCIAL INCENTIVES, the Madison delivers so much to love! DON'T JUST DREAM ABOUT A BRAND-NEW HOME—COME SEE WHAT'S POSSIBLE! Contact us for incentive details and schedule your showing today! HOA $225 per year.

6516 Cowboy Trail Way, Stillwater

311 W 29th Avenue, Stillwater
$190,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1254623 MLS
A HOME WORTH CARING FOR The big tree out front stands as an example of what time and care can grow into. Beneath it, a porch awaits someone to pull up a chair. You pause before going inside. Already, you sense there’s something here you’d like to come home to. Inside, you can see that the house needs care in places. You begin thinking about where you’d start. A color comes to mind. You notice things you’d keep and things you’d love to change. Before you know it, you’re taking a second look at places you passed on the way in. If you enjoy making a house better, you know the feeling. An idea takes hold, and you want to see what you could do with it. You’re willing to give it your time because you can picture yourself living with the result. Imagine finishing your first project here. You put everything away, stand back, and call your loved ones in to look. Every time you walk past, you admire it again. You did that. You get to enjoy it every day. As you settle in, you’ll find the right pace. Some weekends you’ll get things done. Others, you’ll cook dinner on the grill and spend the evening in the back yard. The horses on the property behind you may wander up to the fence for a little attention. You reach over to pet one and take in the view across the field. You don’t have to own it to enjoy it. There’s room to try a garden, let a game of tag run long, or sit and talk while daylight fades. You can build a life here while you’re bringing the house along. Over time, the changes add up. Friends notice the difference, and you pull out your phone to show them how it looked when you started. You remember why you wanted it—the tree, the yard, the possibilities you could see before you’d made a single change. Now you can sit on the porch, look around, and feel proud. You gave this house your attention. You made it a home you love coming back to.

311 W 29th Avenue, Stillwater

113 E Tyler Avenue, Stillwater
$355,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1254574 MLS
Rare opportunity to own a newly constructed home in Stillwater, Oklahoma, conveniently located near Oklahoma State University! Built in 2025 by luxury home builder JS Custom Homes, this property offers exceptional craftsmanship, quality construction, and modern amenities in a location where newer homes of this caliber are difficult to find. Thoughtfully designed with quality, efficiency, and low-maintenance living in mind, this home features a beautiful full-brick exterior, stylish tile flooring, modern fixtures, stainless steel appliances, window coverings, and a Monitronics alarm system. Energy-efficient features include spray foam insulation, a Navien tankless water heater, and a Lennox heating and cooling system with a Wi-Fi-enabled thermostat. Additional highlights include a Class 3 impact-resistant roof and a fully fenced backyard, offering privacy, security, and functionality. An outstanding investment opportunity! This property is currently tenant-occupied with a lease in place through May 31, 2027, at $3,200 per month, representing $38,400 in annual gross rental income. The existing lease provides an established income stream for an investor seeking a newer, quality-built property in the Stillwater market. With its 2025 construction, premium materials, modern finishes, convenient proximity to Oklahoma State University, and established rental income, this property offers a rare combination of quality and investment potential. **Important:** Property is currently leased through May 31, 2027, at $3,200 per month. Buyer must honor the existing lease terms. Showings and possession are subject to tenant rights and lease provisions.

113 E Tyler Avenue, Stillwater

Start Your Search

Copyright © 2026 MLSOK, Inc. This information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Subject to verification by all parties. The listing information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is copyrighted and may not be transmitted, retransmitted, copied, framed, repurposed, or altered in any way for any other site, individual and/or purpose without the express written permission of MLSOK, Inc. Information last updated on .

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!